> Skip to content

Book clubs  •  1 October 2024

 

The Fallen Woman book club questions

A heart-stopping historical adventure to read with your book club.

In Fiona McIntosh's new book, The Fallen Woman, Jane Saville’s manipulative mother banishes her to the English countryside, forcing Jane to live a secretive life to save the family from public shame. Meanwhile, Guy Attwood, heir to a fortune prefers rare-apple hunting over building the family’s business empire.

Soon, Jane and Guy’s paths cross, reminding them both that our greatest strengths are often born from our darkest hours.

Discussion points and questions

  1. Do you think Jane Saville really is a ‘fallen’ woman – or a fortunate one?
  2. Discuss the different ways in which Jane and Guy respond to their familial duties.
  3. In the eyes of ‘society’, Jane and Guy might seem an unlikely couple, but in what ways do they make an ideal match?
  4. ‘Truly, what more could a boy wish for?’ Despite the obvious hardships Harry has faced in his young life, William believes him to be an extremely blessed child. Do you share this view?
  5. ‘For me to give entirely of myself, I would need so much more in a person than how they look or sound, or their station in life.’ How is this comment from Jane reflected in her relationships?
  6. What is your view of Eleanor? Is she a victim or a villain?
  7. In what ways has William been Jane’s ‘guardian angel’, and in what ways is she entirely responsible for her own fate?
  8. Discuss the significance and symbolism of the apple in this novel.
  9. Do you have any sympathy at all for Charlotte’s actions? Why or why not?
  10. What did you make of Guy’s gift for the King?
  11. Who would you cast in a film of The Fallen Woman?
  12. Fiona McIntosh writes across a wide range of genres. Have you read any others, and if so, how do they compare?

Feature Title

The Fallen Woman
The heart-stopping new historical adventure from the bestselling author of The Sugar Palace.
Read more

More features

See all
Book clubs
Foul Play book club questions

A heart-stopping jack Hawksworth novel to read with your book club.

Book clubs
The Sugar Palace book club questions

A heart-stopping romantic adventure to read with your book club.

Article
Better Reading’s Top 100 books of 2024 announced

Penguin Random House is proud to have twenty-four titles on the list this year.

Article
Penguin Noir is back with two events in 2024

Learn about two exciting Penguin Random House author showcases this August!

Article
QUIZ: find your partner in crime this summer

Take this fun quiz to find out which crime novel you should read this summer.

Article
The best book duos to gift for Christmas 2023

Perfect book pairings to give loved ones this holiday season.

Article
The 10 bestselling fiction books of 2023

Check out our top-selling fiction books this year.

Article
What book to gift Mum this Mother’s Day, based on her favourite flower

Find the perfect book based on the blooms she already loves.

Article
Exclusive audiobook content that will inspire you to read more than ever before

Love audiobooks? They’re even better with extra content! Check out some of the audiobooks that include exclusive recorded content for even more enjoyment.

Article
Authors were back on the road in 2022 - and we loved it!

Join us as we travel back in time through 2022 with the authors that hit the road this year.

Article
This is how detective stories have withstood the test of time

Detective stories have been around for over a century, but their popularity persists. Find out who wrote the first detective story and discover a new novel for your ‘must read’ list.

Article
A Behind-the-scenes look at Fiona McIntosh’s book tour

A look inside of Fiona McIntosh's tour for her new book, The Orphans.

Looking for more book club notes?

See all book club notes