Gobsmackingly, Tom Keneally has taken the whole planet for his fictional province, and again and again seems to be at home wherever he lands. Crimes of the Father has a propellant plot. Will justice be done, and will Docherty be allowed to return to Sydney? What develops is a series of cases and confrontations that create as intelligent and comprehensive an account of ecclesiastical reaction to the abuse crisis as I could imagine. Apart from the fictional pleasures of the chase, the novel provides a first-rate summary of the thinking and manoeuvres of all parties caught up in the crisis.
Gerard Windsor, The Australian
Crimes of the Father, a characteristically brave and unflinching novel by the Booker and Miles Franklin prize-winner, examines how the overwhelming majority of Catholic clerics, who may struggle with their vow of celibacy but still manage to give something positive to the world, are coping in an institution where a tiny minority have abused children, too often while the church turns a blind eye. Keneally’s theme is sadly familiar, but in the hands of a world-renowned writer – still, on this evidence, at the height of his powers, and with a long record of shining a light on human frailty and injustice – Crimes of the Father goes way beyond the familiar.
Peter Stanford, The Guardian UK
Keneally's fiction has returned again and again to the themes of thwarted justice and human opportunism. Crimes of the Father is the work of a richly experienced and compassionate writer. It has an honest understanding of a deeply wounded culture.
Michael McGirr, The Age
This is an amazing novel written with insight and compassion. Keneally, with consummate skill, has crafted an unputdownable book, which addresses the issues of celibacy, humanity and the law. Through his characters, Father Frank Docherty, Sara, an ex-nun, and families affected by abuse of a current Monsignor who is now in a position to affect the outcome of legal proceedings against the church. Keneally shows the powerlessness of those left outside seeking recognition.
Maryan Heffernan, Manly Daily
For a man who almost became a Catholic priest [Keneally] gives the church both barrels as he interrogates it for the terrible damage it has wrought upon generations of the faithful, of innocent children whose lives have been stolen. This is must reading.
In his fiction and non-fiction both, Keneally hands a megaphone to the ignored, marginalised and vulnerable, and seeks to represent those damaged by the society or institutions of their time. Crimes of the Father is no exception; as Father Docherty noses out adult survivors of sexual abuse in Sydney, he is drawn into complex moral territory. A nuanced and relevant book, Crimes of the Father is an excellent example of fiction's capacity to pull apart and explore polarising contemporary problems.
Cara Lennon, BMA magazine, Canberra
A searing and intelligent novel that pits the church against the law - and its own.
A tight plot rife with ethical and emotional dilemmas. Crimes of the Father may be seen as a topical, neatly-constructed crime novel and/or as Keneally's indictment of the Irish Catholic Church to which he is affiliated by birth and upbringing if no longer by personal allegiance. It is also in part a powerful reminiscence of an exciting time of liturgical fervour and lay participation that was by no means confined to Catholicism.
Katharine England, Adelaide Advertiser
Readable, timely, wise.
Paul Sharrad, Sydney Review of Books
Keneally certainly does not skirt around the horrors of paedophilia, he is a gentle and compassionate writer far more interested in understanding than condemning … Crimes of the Father ... deserves great credit for treating this sensitive issue without an ounce of sensationalism. Thomas Keneally's North Cork forebears would be proud of him.
Keneally is extraordinarily generous in his story-telling … the force and resonance of the issue in question – together with Keneally’s wise and thoughtful treatment of it – make for another hugely satisfying read from one of the world’s great writers.
Pulsing with rage at ecclesiastical complacency, it’s a deeply discomfiting (but never prurient) quest for redress, narrated with clarity and urgency.
A provocative and powerful study of abusers and the abused. It captures the honourable priests determined to expose the outrage and the church hierarchy equally determined to discredit them. Most poignantly, it depicts ordinary Catholics caught in the crossfire . . . The writing is most powerful when I conveys the raw pain of the victims and the twisted psyches of their abusers . . . Above all, Keneally exposes the cynical casuistry of a church determined to fight critics down to "its last lawyer", an institution that puts its survival above its soul.
Michael Arditti, Guardian
A convincing argument for the power of fiction to get under the skin of a great contemporary controversy.
James Marriott, The Times
September 18, 2017
October 31, 2016
October 31, 2016
RHA eBooks Adult
Docherty Comes to Australia
1 July 1996
Sarah Fagan was driving a cab. Some might think her cab-driving a pathetic attempt to meet men. In fact, it was a genuine attempt to allow a recovery of her brain, which was depleted, and a revival of her spirit, which had been rendered numb from all that had happened to her.
Driving was an art, but it also allowed intellectual vacuity, plain rituals of conversation. And if Sarah did not want to converse on the issue of why a woman like her was driving a cab, she would say, ‘We’re all filling in for my husband, who has cancer.’ The ‘we’re all’ implied a tough family hanging together in a crisis; that she was not, therefore, in favour of being messed around by passengers. She suspected that a decision about whether she would stay in neutral gear for the rest of her life, or might pull herself out of it, would most probably arise not from conscious thought or frantic self-analysis, but with her brain muted by routine. Listening to and exchanging banalities with her passengers, she hoped she would hear some healing neutral words. She might then learn to live in the same room as the tiger, the flesh-tearing fury.Continue Reading