> Skip to content

Book clubs  •  2 January 2024


Eleanor Jones is Not a Murderer Book Club Questions

Amy Doak on the creation of Eleanor Jones is Not a Murderer.

I have always loved a good puzzle. Raised in a household where crime shows and movies were considered quality family time (who could guess the culprit first!), my mother also introduced me to mystery novels at a young age. When I was little, The Famous Five, The Secret Seven and Encyclopedia Brown were the launchpads to Trixie Belden, Nancy Drew and The Dana Sisters. Then, as I got older, I found Agatha Christie, Mary Higgins Clark and Sue Grafton. Later, novelists such as Karin Slaughter, Val McDermid, Elizabeth George, Minette Walters and Tess Gerritsen all were firm favourites. These days, I love Aussie authors like Michael Robotham, Candice Fox and Margaret Hickey. Anything that inspires critical thinking, sets a cracking pace, keeps me on the edge of my seat and offers me the perfect escape are the books I look for. The idea of writing one someday has always been a dream.

I also love fabulous characters, a quality support cast and an element of humour. When I was growing up, shows like Buffy the Vampire Slayer (with an excellent group of friends) and cosy mysteries like Death In Paradise (fun side characters, a murder to solve) have always offered quality comfort viewing! I think my media consumption over the years has most definitely impacted my writing. Eleanor, as a voice, arrived fully formed in my head – almost like a real-life person – and Min, Troy, Alfie and Namita came soon after.

When I was a teen, I would have loved a book like Eleanor Jones is Not a Murderer. Something fun and action-packed, with enough heart to make you want to be a part of this unique group. To me, books will always serve as a way to understand others and a place to escape into a world that makes you feel good. Perhaps that is the appeal of crime for me. The bad guy is always found, the mysteries are solved, and the ending is a happy one.

I’ve been writing since I was a child, but I always believed that writing novels – and being published – was something that happened to other people. Certainly not me! Over the years, I’ve become involved in my local writers’ festival, and I’ve met some wonderful authors who have become mentors and friends. One of them, Katrina Nannestad (who is an incredibly talented middle-grade fiction author) read the first few pages of Eleanor Jones as a rough draft and suggested I write it in the present tense rather than the past. With that feedback, and the positive nudge that this was a story worth writing, I was able to keep going – and I’m so glad I did!

Amy Doak

Discussion points and questions

  • Amy Doak has been inspired by a lot of the authors and stories she read growing up.
    Do you think you’ve been influenced by the books and stories you read as a child and as you grew older? Is there a particular author you’ve tried to learn from?
    What about that author’s work attracted you?
  • Have you read any of the authors Amy mentioned above? Can you see these authors’ influence in the novel Eleanor Jones is Not a Murderer?
  • How often are your reading habits influenced by authors and what they are reading (instead of what they are writing!)? For example, do you read the ‘end of year’ articles that often appear at the start of summer, where authors talk about their favourite reads of the year? What have been your favourite reads this year? Did they include any other crime fiction novels?
  • Amy mentions that she originally wrote the story in past tense, and then changed it to present tense for the final version. What difference do you think being in the past tense would have made? How do you think this has affected the ‘voice’ of Eleanor Jones?
  • How has Amy woven her own love of books into the character of Eleanor Jones? 
  • What is your favourite trope? Has Amy used it in Eleanor Jones is Not a Murderer?
  • A key murder mystery trope is the red herring. There are many characters and situations in the story that aren’t what they seem to be. For example, Ethan isn’t the delinquent bad boy everyone thinks he is . . . What are some other red herrings in the story? How has the author used them to throw the reader off track?
  • Codes and patterns often play a big part in mystery novels. How has the author utilised this in Eleanor Jones is Not a Murderer
  • What did you think of the characters in the story? Are they realistic? Why or why not?
  • If this novel were going to be made into a movie or television show, who would you cast as the main characters?
  • Do you think Eleanor is a reliable narrator? 
  • At the end of the book, there is an ad for a sequel. What do you think Eleanor Jones Can’t Keep a Secret will be about? Can you think of possible ways Amy could expand on the characters and their relationships?


Want more? Read a Q&A with Amy here!

Feature Title

Eleanor Jones is Not a Murderer
Karen McManus and Holly Jackson meets Fleur Ferris in this fast-paced YA murder mystery.
Read more

More features

See all
Debut authors share their best tips for aspiring authors

The Fresh Voices of 2023 share their advice with fellow writers. Whether you’re aspiring to get your book published or looking for writing tips, these words of wisdom will help.

The rare success of one author's open submission

An author and editor share the unique publication story of Amy Doak's debut novel, Eleanor Jones is Not a Murderer.

The 10 most anticipated YA books of 2023

Check out 10 of the most-anticipated YA books to read in 2023. Trust us, add them to your TBR now!

QUIZ: Which YA book should you ask for this Christmas?

Take this quiz to find out which YA book you should put on your wishlist this year.

Some of the most anticipated YA books of 2024

Exciting upcoming books for YA readers.

Book clubs
The Sugar Palace book club questions

A heart-stopping romantic adventure to read with your book club.

Book clubs
On a Bright Hillside in Paradise book club questions

A book about faith and family to read with your book club.

Book clubs
As the River Rises book club questions

A medical romance to read with your book club.

Book clubs
Doll's Eye book club questions

A story of love, loss and survival to read with your book club.

Book clubs
Love Match book club questions

An Australian country romance to read with your book club.

Book clubs
Perfect-ish book club questions

A smart, funny and heartfelt anti-romcom to read with your book club.

Looking for more book club notes?

See all book club notes