> Skip to content

Recipe  •  8 May 2025

 

Buttermilk Pie

Here in Texas, the land of cattle and roughly 130 million acres of ranchland, buttermilk flows thick and heavy-not from their livestock (Texans are in the beef business), but rather into their mixing bowls.

Perhaps through veins too, as every recipe from this state includes it. According to community cookbooks, Texas homemakers have long preferred buttermilk over regular milk when making their pancakes, biscuits, cakes, and even dressings. I'm almost tempted to ask if any Texans take their coffee with the stuff.

The Buttermilk Pie is an old mainstay and shares many similarities with the southland's Chess Pie and other Great Depression pies like the sugar cream, the vinegar, and the poor man's. The distinction is of course in the details, and with our pie of concern, I promise you the details are very good. A tangy, smooth vanilla custard awaits you atop a flaky crust, the elixir to melt away the troubles of a hot day. The Buttermilk Pie has a complexity in flavor that belies its simplistic preparation. It emanates the vibes of a grandmother's love.

It was such a favorite of former first lady of Texas Laura Bush that she developed her own recipe for the pie, to which she added coconut and a healthy topping of whipped cream. In Hays County, a ways north of San Antonio, the town of Kyle has developed a reputation as "The Pie Capital of Texas." Julie Albertson, "The Pie Queen," runs the Texas Pie Company there, where Buttermilk Pie is a favorite on the menu. Julie supposedly wields the magical power to imbue her custom pies within cantations meant to aid lonesome souls in finding lovers. She in fact found her husband by baking one of these "love pies."

Though I've yet to master spell craft and other matters of the occult, I feel confident that you, and indeed Texans, will find love within this recipe. Feel free to omit the coconut if you aren't partial, but I do think Miss Laura had a pretty good point with its inclusion.

Serves: 9-inch pie
Prep Time: 10 minutes
Bake Time: 60 minutes
Cool Time: 1 hour

INGREDIENTS

  • 4 eggs
  • 1â…“ cups (265g) granulated sugar
  • 1 cup (235ml) buttermilk
  • 1 tbsp vanilla extract
  • Zest and juice of ½ lemon
  • 2 tbsp all-purpose flour
  • ¼ tsp salt
  • ½ tsp freshly grated nutmeg
  • 1 cup (110g) sweetened, shredded coconut (optional)
  • 1 single-crust Pie Crust (page 17)
  • 1 egg, beaten together with 3 tbsp water, for egg wash
  • Whipped cream or whipped topping, for serving

 

METHOD

  1. In a large bowl, whisk together thoroughly the eggs, sugar, buttermilk, vanilla extract, lemon zest and juice, flour, salt, and nutmeg, in this order, until well combined. Add the coconut, if desired, and let the mixture stand for 15 minutes while preparing the crust.

  2. Preheat the oven to 325°F (165°C).

  3. Roll out and fit your prepared pie crust into a deep 9-inch (23cm) pie dish. Brush the crimped edges and the bottom of the crust with the egg wash.

  4. Pour the filling into the crust and bake for 50 to 60 minutes, or until the top has lightly browned and only wobbles slightly in the center when jostled. Remove and place on a wire rack for at least 1 hour to cool before serving. Serve garnished with whipped cream or whipped topping.

Feature Title

Baking Across America
Join B. Dylan Hollis, bestselling author of Baking Yesteryear, on a cross-country culinary journey with 100 uniquely American recipes
Read more

More features

See all recipes
Recipe
Kool-Aid Pie

To a giant plastic pitcher, its rim etched and toughened by years of use, I watched my two older brothers, Tyler and Jason, add an obscene amount of grape Kool-Aid, deepening the liquid within to a dark purple.

Recipe
Beignets

It's hard to fathom it, but the loud and proud thrumming of the Louisiana we walk today is but a fraction of what came before.

Recipe
PB&J Cheesecake

A classic sandwich, transformed into a scrumptious cheesecake.

Recipe
Tomato Soup Cake

Tomato soup . . . as a cake? What will they think of next!

Recipe
Food for the Gods

An unorthodox, god-like dessert popularised in the 1900s.

Article
The best book duos to gift for Christmas 2023

Perfect book pairings to give loved ones this holiday season.

Article
10 fun facts about B. Dylan Hollis

Learn all about TikTok sensation and cookbook author, B. Dylan Hollis.

Recipe
Grated Tomato Linguine

A delicious pasta sauce made with the freshest in-season tomatoes.

Recipe
Khorashi with Buftek

Nadiya Hussain's stunning khoshari, a dish layered with different flavours and textures including rice, lentils, chickpeas and served with a side of marinated steak, has a real special occasion feel, perfect for Eid celebrations, dinner parties or whenever you want to impress.

Recipe
Dinner Rolls

The ultimate guide for making dinner rolls from scratch, from Dessert Course.

Recipe
Tagine de Poulet: Chicken Tagine served with Beid Hamine and Rice

Nadiya Hussain's hearty tagine recipe is layered with warming spices and fragrant preserved lemon, and packed with tender chicken, potato and olives.

Recipe
Cinnamon Coffee Cake

The beauty of the Reverse Creaming Method is the fine and velvety texture it helps create. The way that it is able to accomplish this plush interior is by minimizing gluten formation.

Looking for more recipes?

See all recipes