> Skip to content

Book clubs  •  7 May 2026

 

When Lemons Give You Life Discussion Questions

When Lemons Give You Life by Anna Johnston Discussion Questions

1. Griff grapples with guilt and regret and has challenges navigating his identity and relationships. Which of these issues resonated with you the most, and why? How did they shape his character throughout the story?

2. How does the author’s portrayal of dementia reinforce your understanding of the condition and its impact on individuals and families?

3. How does Lisa's late ADHD diagnosis shape her self-perception and relationships? How does it reflect broader societal challenges faced by women with undiagnosed neurodiversity?

4. How does the book highlight the challenges faced by LGBTQ+ elders in finding inclusive care? How does Griff's experience shed light on the challenges and importance of safe spaces for queer individuals in their later years?

5. Redemption is a recurring theme in the story. How do Griff and Lisa each seek second chances, and what do their journeys teach us about forgiveness and personal growth? What does their journey teach us about the complexities of sibling relationships? Do you think Griff's actions ultimately redeemed him in Lisa's eyes? Why or why not?

6. Lisa and Griff both make sacrifices for their loved ones. How do their actions reflect the complexities of love and loyalty, and where do you think the line should be drawn? How does the book explore the idea of love as both a burden and a privilege?

7. Food plays a central role in the story, bringing people together and evoking memories. How does the act of sharing a meal serve as a metaphor for healing and connection in the book?

8. Cooking serves as a powerful tool for healing and connection. How does Griff use food to mend relationships, process his emotions, and create a sense of community? What does this say about the transformative power of cooking in the face of grief and adversity?

9. How does the portrayal of Sunny Glen Aged Care Facility reflect broader societal issues in elderly care, and what changes do you think are necessary to create more compassionate and inclusive environments?

10. When Griff ultimately chooses honesty, what do you think motivated this decision, and how does his honesty impact his relationship with Lisa and his own journey toward redemption?

11. Beau plays a quiet but powerful role in the narrative. In what ways does he shape Griff and Lisa’s reconciliation, both during his life and beyond it?

Feature Title

When Lemons Give You Life

An enchanting, heart-stirring novel about rediscovering joy when life has lost its flavour, from the author of the bestselling The Borrowed Life of Frederick Fife (recently acquired by Netflix).

Read more

More features

See all
Book clubs
The Borrowed Life of Frederick Fife book club questions

A heartwarming debut novel to read with your book club about mistaken identity, loneliness, and the quest for belonging.

Article
Better Reading’s Top 100 books of 2025 announced

We’re happy to share that an impressive twenty-five Penguin Random House titles made the list this year.

Article
Congratulations to the Penguin authors who made the Indie Book Awards Shortlist 2025

The Indie Book Awards Shortlist 2025 has been announced, and Penguin Random House Australia has four books on the list!

Article
What the most popular books of 2024 say about our year of reading

From cookbooks to thrillers, these are the books that dominated reading trends in 2024

Q&A
Anna Johnston shares the real-life inspiration behind her debut novel

We caught up with Anna Johnston to learn more about The Borrowed Life of Frederick Fife, her writing process, and which fictional character she’d most like to have dinner with.

Book clubs
The Correspondent book club questions

Book club questions: The Correspondent by Virginia Evans

Book clubs
One Night at Silver Lake book club questions

One Night at Silver Lake book club questions.

Book clubs
Dove book club questions

Book club questions for Dove by Georgia Harper.

Book clubs
Beth Is Dead book club questions

Start your Beth Is Dead book club discussion with these questions.

Book clubs
What Is Left For Us book club questions

Book club questions for What Is Left For Us by Sophie Stern.

Book clubs
Vow of Eternal Night book club questions

Book club questions for Vow of Eternal Night by Lily Crozier: a moving, gothic romantasy perfect for your book club.

Book clubs
Kin book club questions

A moving novel about mothers and daughters, friendship and sisterhood, to read with your book club.

Looking for more book club notes?

See all book club notes