> Skip to content

Article  •  1 September 2016


September 1917

'Bite and hold’: the grinding tactics of Field Marshal Haig.

In September 1917 world events were closing in on Flanders, denying Field Marshal Douglas Haig any hope of support from Russia and little from France.

Russia’s armies were ‘fast disintegrating’. Thousands were deserting. Lenin’s calls for insurrection were curdling into bloody reality, easing pressure on the German units along the Eastern Front, many of whom were now packing up and heading west.

In France, Pe´tain’s exhausted armies were not expected to resume full strength until early 1918. And the Americans were delayed, not due to arrive in force until mid-1918. That left the British and little Dominions as the only forces capable of offensive action, which might have counselled restraint, possibly a defensive war. But Haig felt the imperative to attack, and attack again, even though the original goal, the Belgian coast, was beyond his reach.

Few supported him, or pressed him to persist. The French generals, notably Foch, were against the Flanders Offensive; or, like Pe´tain, they went along with it because it bought more time for their forces to recover. Haig’s own commanders had advised against him continuing in the terrible conditions.

Prime Minister Lloyd George and the War Policy Committee were, of course, consistently opposed (even if they failed to act). According to the latest Cabinet statement to this effect, issued on 20 July, ‘on no account’ should Flanders degenerate into ‘protracted, costly and indecisive operations’ like the Somme. By early September, that’s exactly what it had become. But, in a manifest failure of political leadership, the Cabinet did nothing. Government inertia, rather than any overt support, gave Haig the nod to keep bashing away.

Haig and his generals chose a method of grinding tactical warfare, dubbed ‘bite and hold’. Here is how it looked from the German perspective, as described by a German witness:

‘Take a section of the enemy front twenty kilometres wide and three kilometres deep, batter it for fourteen days with a few thousand guns of all calibres, cover it in a few hundred thousands of gas shells, turn everything completely upside down, until nothing could possibly be still moving as far as
is humanly possible – then occupy it by way of ten waves [of infantry] supported by machine guns, tanks and planes proceeding in sequence one after the other and protected by a fiery dome...

‘Then advance the artillery through the shell hole area and prevent the enemy from taking any effective counter-action by continuous barrage fire and unceasing individual attacks. After ten days, you take another section twenty kilometres wide and some kilometres deep and repeat the same calculation. And repeat it until you have reached your goal.’

Such were Allied intentions in September. And so, upon this blameless scrape of earth, Haig’s generals prepared to visit a torrent of fire on a scale mankind had never before inflicted on his fellow man, at the end of which every German soldier caught inside the targeted area should be dead, mutilated, gassed or incoherent. To this end, the Allies ordered up an unprecedented number of heavy guns.


Keep your eyes out for the next in this series of posts by Paul Ham, tracking the key moments and turning points in the Battle of Passchendaele.

Passchendaele Paul Ham

Passchendaele epitomises everything that was most terrible about the Western Front. The photographs never sleep of this four-month battle, fought from July to November 1917, the worst year of the war: blackened tree stumps rising out of a field of mud, corpses of men and horses drowned in shell holes, terrified soldiers huddled in trenches awaiting the whistle.

Buy now
Buy now

More features

See all
12th October 1917

The opening stages of the First Battle of Passchendaele.

16th August 1917

The Battle of Langemarck: an Irish tragedy.

31st July 1917

The Battle of Passchendaele begins…

The 2021 Booker Prize shortlist revealed

The shortlist for the 2021 Booker Prize has been announced, with four Penguin Random House novels named.

'Utterly broken': The Resilience Project co-founder’s powerful admission

Hugh van Cuylenburg was being interviewed on a national radio station when he surprised himself with an admission.

The song behind The What On Earth Institute of Wonder, by Lisa Nicol

Light-emitting Mushrooms and the High Priestess of Soul; The song behind The What On Earth Institute of Wonder.

Simple reading hacks for time-poor dads

Two authors — who are also dads — share their tips on how fathers can get a moment to themselves.

The four hidden health benefits of reading

Reading offers us entertainment and a quick escape from reality, but did you know about these other hidden health benefits?

The top books for dad this Father's Day

Show them you know them by picking a book that perfectly matches your dad.

QUIZ: What book best suits your dad for Father's Day

Take our quiz to discover which books match your dad's personality so you can buy the perfect Father's Day gift.

Five easy hacks to declutter your bookshelf

The top tips for sprucing your bookshelf during the annual spring clean.

The habit that can lift your mood in just six minutes

There is one act that will help lift your mood in just minutes as we prepare to enter the new spring season.

Looking for more articles?

See all articles