> Skip to content
  • Published: 6 May 2025
  • ISBN: 9780857505880
  • Imprint: Bantam
  • Format: Trade Paperback
  • Pages: 400
  • RRP: $34.99

It Should Have Been You

Extract

PROLOGUE

I have to kill my sister.

I can’t. I can’t do this.

I glance across the kitchen.

I have to. I have no choice.

My face is wet, my throat is bone dry. There’s a buzzing inside my head, the sound of abject terror.

‘Do it,’ my sister says in a croaky whisper, as if it’s that simple, as if killing her is something I can do.

She’s my family, my blood, one of the three people I love most in the world.

Tears slide down her face. Greta never cries. She’s the strong one, the practical one. And now I have to do something unforgiveable.

From outside comes the sound of fireworks. The Oakpark summer party. Our neighbours eating and drinking on the green, oblivious to what’s happening in my kitchen.

‘I love you so much.’ My voice is hoarse, my limbs are loose. ‘I’m so sorry.’

The sky lights up with fireworks as she rolls up her sleeve.

My throat contracts with grief.

I lean towards her, Death come to take her. A sob lurches through me.

The syringe feels like nothing. It should feel cold or hot or heavy, something to signify the power it holds, but it doesn’t. It’s light and nothingy. I glance around the kitchen one more time. How is this happening? Everything looks just as it always does. The scratched wooden table of our childhood, the bluepainted cupboards, the knotty hardwood floors.

My hand shakes as I inch the tip of the needle towards my sister’s vein. She closes her eyes.

‘I’m sorry,’ I say again, and push the syringe, flooding her blood with poison.

To my horror, it’s instantaneous. As the dusky sky lights pink and gold to the pop of fireworks, Greta slips sideways and slides off the chair. Her prone figure on my kitchen floor. In seconds, it’s over.

Ten days is all it took for my world to implode. Ten days, four deaths, one teen in hospital, one in police custody, my family destroyed.

And all because of a text.


It Should Have Been You Andrea Mara

They came for you. But they got the wrong house... A gripping, unputdownable thriller from the No. 1 bestselling author of NO ONE SAW A THING. Andrea Mara turns ordinary fears into extraordinary thrillers, and this is her best book yet.

Buy now
Buy now

More extracts

See all
Devil’s Kitchen

‘We know you’re a cop,’ Matt said.

My Father's House

Grunting, sullen, in spumes of leaden smoke, the black Daimler with diplomatic number plate noses onto Via Diciannove, beads of sleet fizzling on its hood.

Triple Cross

Suzanne Liu lived for days like this, days when her world seemed like a great game and the sweet smell of opportunity and cash hung in the air like lavender and sage.

No Plan B

The meeting was held in a room with no windows.

Clive Cussler's Hellburner

That’s his third course correction, sir,” Santos said. “There’s no doubt he’s chasing us.”

The Butcher and the Wren

Jeremy hears the screaming through the vents.

Act of Oblivion

If you had set out in the summer of 1660 to travel the four miles from Boston to Cambridge, Massachusetts, the first house you would have come to after crossing the Charles River would have been the Gookins’.

The Girl in the Castle

It starts with a girl, half naked and screaming.

Stay Awake

Starbursts blink from streetlights like they’re sharing a secret as I wake to find myself slumped in the back of a cab, without any recollection of how I got here, or where I’m going.

Blowback

It’s a brisk autumn day in June in one of South Africa’s largest cities, and thirty-year-old Benjamin Lucas is enjoying an off day from his South African Diamond Tour.

Denizen: Winner of the Penguin Literary Prize

I was twenty-four when Christian was born, much younger than I’d ever expected to become a father.

Escape

He’s here somewhere. I know it. And the girl might still be alive.

penguin pop image
penguin pop image