> Skip to content

Book clubs  •  31 May 2022


The Making of Her book club notes

An absorbing story to discuss with your book club.

The Making of Her is a page-turning mother-daughter love story that spans across decades charting one woman's journey to escape the legacy of the society that shaped her. 

It is an absorbing novel that celebrates the strength of women, with many thought-provoking themes that make it a perfect read for book club. 

Discussion points and questions:

  • Why do you think the novel is titled The Making of Her?
  • The story is set in Dublin. In what ways do you think the city shaped the Egans' lives?
  • What path do you think Joan's life would have taken if she hadn't received Emma's letter? 
  • How did you interpret Joan's decision to sleep with Martin before he goes to London?
  • Did you empathise with Martin? And if so, when and why?
  • At one point Martin asks Joan: 'Why can't we leave the past where it belongs?' Why do you think he finds this so easy to do, and Joan finds it so hard?
  • Discuss the role of men throughout the story. 
  • Were you surprised by Emma's decision at the airport towards the end of the novel?
  • What did you make of Joan and Carmel's relationship as the novel went on, and of Carmel's forgiveness? 
  • How does social class affect the lives of the characters in the novel?
  • In this multigenerational story, we see the reverberations of the choices made by grandparents and parents, and the scars they have left on Joan, Carmel and Emma. In what ways do those scars reveal themselves, and is it possible to break the cycle?
  • How did you interpret the ending? For you, was the major plot of the novel about the cost of keeping secrets or the power to choose?

Feature Title

The Making of Her
The Making of Her is a page-turning mother-daughter love story, spanning the 1960s to 1990s, charting one woman’s journey to escape the legacy of the society that shaped her.
Read more

More features

See all
Book clubs
The Studio Girls book club Questions

A sumptuous, nostalgic book about the Golden Age of cinema to read with your book club

Books to read if you loved Lessons in Chemistry

What to read after Lessons in Chemistry.

Meet the characters from Lessons in Chemistry

Learn about a few of the major characters from Lessons in Chemistry by Bonnie Garmus.

Rachael Johns shares her trick for getting words onto the page

We caught up with Rachael Johns to learn about her writing routines, favourite rom-coms and new book The Other Bridget.

The 10 bestselling fiction books of 2023

Check out our top-selling fiction books this year.

Some of the most anticipated books of 2024

From authors including Rachael Johns, Amor Towles, Leigh Bardugo and so many others!

The best books to read with your book club in spring 2023

These are the Penguin Random House books that over 48,000 book clubs voted as the best group reads this October.

A useful guide to Anne Enright

A guide to author Anne Enright and her books.

Didn't get to Europe this year? These 3 books will transport you there

Revisit three Amanda Hampson books to experience European summer from the comfort of your living room.

Contemplating a life change? You need to read this cosy Japanese fiction

Reviewers agree – if you’re feeling in a rut, it’s time to read What You Are Looking For is in the Library. Learn more and see what readers are saying about it.

QUIZ: Which Clive Cussler character are you?

Ever wondered which Clive Cussler character you’re most like? Take this quiz to figure out which adventurous protagonist you share similarities with.

QUIZ: Which One Of Us Is Lying Character are you?

Are you most like Bronwyn, Addy, Nate or Cooper?

Looking for more book club notes?

See all book club notes