> Skip to content

Book clubs  •  6 March 2018

 

Only the Animals book club notes

Book clubs will see history from a different perspective in these short stories from Ceridwen Dovey.

In Ceridwen Dovey's Only the Animals, the souls of ten animals caught up in human conflicts over the last century tell their astonishing stories of life and death, sharing their view of humans at our brutal worst and our creative best.
 

Questions and discussion points:
 

  • Consider the way in which each story addresses the quote from Boria Sax that gives the collection its title: ‘What does it mean to be human? Perhaps only the animals can know.’ (page 179)
  • This book incorporates the ideas of a number of writers besides those named in it. Discuss the use of the work of as many of those as you recognise.
  •  ‘The Bones’ draws on several Henry Lawson pieces, along with a true incident, the massacre of blacks at Hospital Creek. When the camel protests his innocence with the comment, ‘I had only arrived a few years ago, how could I have done anything wrong?’ (page 11), does this reflect anything of modern Australia to you?
  • Do any of the other stories set many decades ago encapsulate something essential about modern life, in your opinion?
  • The cat comments of Colette that ‘she and I consider ourselves hybrids of a sort, never quite able to fit within the boundaries of our sex or species, always feeling we’re a smudgy, mongrel character’. (page 26) Discuss the value of this standpoint.
  • In ‘Hundstage’, Himmler expresses a sentiment which the dog-narrator finds very beautiful (page 76, second paragraph). How did you respond on reading this scene? Does the dog’s blind loyalty to its master bring you to any greater empathy for those German people brainwashed during World War II?
  • Discuss the portrayal of the experience of motherhood in this collection: Colette, for example, was ambivalent about it, Plath embraced it as part of her work, the dolphin had her own view. Does motherhood represent something wider in these stories, do you think? Is a parallel implied between the responsibility for life created and life tamed?
  • The bears’ story is the only one told in the third person rather than the first: why do you think this is?
  • Discuss the way in which these stories throw into relief the primal versus the civilised aspects of human beings.
  • Only the Animals deftly avoids anthropomorphising, with two stories being deliberate exceptions to this: the mussel’s, with its characterisation of Kerouc, and the chimpanzee’s, in which the chimps are groomed to behave like humans. Do you think these two have particular points to make about animal–human connections?
  • The dolphin wonders of humans, ‘Why do you sometimes treat other people as humans and sometimes as animals? And why do you sometimes treat creatures as animals and sometimes as humans?’ (page 206) What’s your response to this question?
  • There’s a suggestion that these stories may have been solicited by an unseen curator – the dolphin reveals on page 204 that she was asked to write the story of her death. Did you have a sense of that while reading? If so, what did you make of it, and if not, did you wonder at how the stories came into being?
  • Apart from those mentioned in the book summary above, what other questions do these stories raise for you?
  • Do you think the two stories that bookend the collection, the camel’s and the parrot’s, serve a particular function?

Only the Animals Ceridwen Dovey

An animal's-eye view of humans at our brutal worst and our creative best, Only the Animals asks us to believe again in the redemptive power of reading and writing fiction.

Buy now
Buy now

More features

See all
Book clubs
The Paper Palace book club notes

A magnificent literary pick for book club.

Book clubs
A Slow Fire Burning book club notes

An exciting new thriller from the author of The Girl on the Train to discuss with your book club.

Book clubs
How to start a book club

Get your very own book club off the ground with these tips from The Wattle Island Book Club author.

Book clubs
The Farmer’s Friend book club notes

An uplifting Australian drama from rural midwife and bestselling author Fiona McArthur.

Book clubs
Wattle Island Book Club book club notes

A story filled with courage, passion and hope to share with your reading group.

Book clubs
Cutters End book club notes

A desert highway. A remote town. A murder that won’t stay hidden.

Book clubs
The Garden of Hopes and Dreams book club notes

A timely and uplifting story about the importance of community and connection from much-loved author Barbara Hannay.

Book clubs
Once There Were Wolves book club notes

Part thriller, part redemptive love story, and sure to be a crowd-pleaser at your next book club meeting.

Book clubs
Mirror Man book club notes

Ponder whether one life is worth more than another with Fiona McIntosh's latest thriller.

Book clubs
The Deep book club notes

This heart-stopping thriller set on the rugged coast of Tasmania is an excellent choice for book club.

Book clubs
The Coconut Children book club notes

An award-winning pick for your next book club meeting.

Book clubs
The Rabbits book club notes

A (Penguin Literary Prize) winning pick for book club.

Looking for more book club notes?

See all book club notes