> Skip to content

Recipe  •  22 November 2023

 

Rainbow cookie pie

A decadent chewy, colourful cookie cake that's perfect for any occasion.

Perfect for any birthday party, this cookie pie has bright layers of rainbow chocolate inside our original chewy cookie recipe, topped with M&Ms and sprinkles.

Serves: 8 or 12

 

INGREDIENTS

Cookie dough

  • 190g (1 stick plus 4 tbsp) unsalted butter
  • 150g (¾ cup packed) light soft brown sugar
  • 150g (⅔, cup) caster sugar
  • 1 egg plus 1 egg yolk
  • 300g (2½ cups) plain flour
  • 1 tsp baking powder
  • 40g (2 tbsp) golden syrup
  • 60g (2¼oz) bake-stable sprinkles, plus extra for topping
  • 60g (2¼oz) M&Ms, plus extra for topping
  • 150g (5½oz) white chocolate chips

Filling

  • 1kg (2Ib 4oz) white chocolate spread (or 1kg/2Ib 4oz white chocolate mixed with 80ml/5½ tbsp vegetable oil)
  • Pink, orange, yellow, green, blue, indigo and violet oil-based food colourings

Decoration (optional)

  • 100g (6½ tbsp) unsalted butter
  • 180g (1⅓, cups) icing sugar
  • 3-5 drops of vanilla extract

Special Equipment

  • Mixer or hand-held electric whisk
  • 20cm (Bin) round cake tin, lined
  • Piping bag and open star nozzle

 

METHOD

  1. To make the cookie dough, put the butter and both sugars into a mixer and, using the paddle attachment, cream together on a high speed (or use a hand-held electric whisk). Add the egg and yolk and mix.

  2. Sift in the flour and baking powder, then add the remaining cookie dough ingredients. Combine slowly until a dough forms and the sprinkles, M&Ms and chocolate chips are evenly distributed.

  3. Press a thick layer of dough evenly into the bottom of the lined tin. Press more mixture around the sides of the tin and leave a gap about 2.5cm (lin) from the top. Cover and set aside the remaining cookie dough.

  4. Melt the white chocolate spread (or white chocolate mixed with oil) in a bowl in the microwave and divide between seven bowls. Use the oil-based food colourings to colour each bowl a colour of the rainbow. Carefully pour the last rainbow colour (violet) into the cookie base and set in the freezer until tacky (about 10 minutes). Repeat with each colour, finishing with pink. Return to the freezer.

  5. Preheat the oven to 195°C (175°C fan/385° F/Gas 5½).

  6. After at least 30 minutes in the freezer, remove the tin and use the remaining cookie dough to make a lid, place it on top and seal the edges. Push some extra M&Ms into the top along with a handful of sprinkles. Bake for 30 minutes. Leave to cool completely in the tin, then chill in the fridge overnight.

  7. Slice the pie evenly into 8 or 12 pieces. If decorating with buttercream, whip the butter on a high speed until whitened. Sift in the icing sugar, add the vanilla extract and mix until combined. Load a piping bag with an open star nozzle and pipe whips on top of each slice. Finish with more sprinkles and M&Ms.

Feature Title

Finch Bakery Disco Bakes and Party Cakes
More than 70 showstopping treats for every occasion.
Read more

More features

See all recipes
Recipe
Coconut & raspberry Viennese whirls

Jam-filled shortbread swirl biscuits with coconut twist.

Recipe
Verena’s potato salad

Growing up in Germany, Verena remembers two camps when it came to potato salad: camp mayo and camp oil/broth.

Recipe
Chicken and veg kebabs

One of my guilty go-to takeaways, perfect with a homemade flatbread and a yogurt dip. It’s so moreish and a lot cheaper than ordering in.

Recipe
Courgette & leek ijeh (Arabic frittata)

What better way to welcome the weekend than with the smell and sound of frying herb-loaded ijeh?

Recipe
Samkeh Harra (fish with tahini sauce and nuts)

‘Fish doesn’t have to be boring—my mother taught me that. Samkeh harra translates to “spicy fish,” though it’s more about a gentle kick than true heat. It’s a perfect balance of creamy, nutty tahini and the crunch of golden, roasted nuts. Oh, I do love nuts! I usually overload my plate so you almost can’t see the fish anymore, but that’s me. The nuts bring a deep, toasty richness that elevates the dish into something truly irresistible.’

Recipe
Rick Stein’s hazelnut pavlovas with white chocolate and dark berry sauce

These festive pavlovas are dipped in white chocolate and topped with toasted hazelnuts, cream and berry sauce to make an impressive dessert.

Recipe
Portuguese Chicken and Fries

Think of this as exactly what Nando’s wishes it was: vibrant spicy chicken with crispy skin served with crunchy fries and a spicy dipping sauce. Piri piri chillies aren’t widely available in Australia, unless you grow them yourself, but bird’s-eye chillies are easy to find and they do the trick.

Recipe
Cherry clafoutis

I don’t remember much about the circumstances of my first cherry clafoutis. But I must have loved the classic French farmhouse dessert, because I’ve been trying to reproduce that first custardy, almond-scented pancake ever since.

Recipe
Panang-style beef with coconut rice

Not quite a red curry, not quite a satay, this dish is the best of both worlds, inspired by Thai flavours and it is divine. It’s a throw-and-go recipe and I know we all love those at BOL. Perfect served with creamy coconut rice, some sliced red chilli and flatbreads.

Recipe
Stir-fried peppers with paneer – Kadai mirch paneer

Camellia Punjabi's recipe for the classic North Indian dish of stir-fried peppers with paneer is flavoured with a medley of spices and aromatics and makes for a brilliant vegetarian dish.

Recipe
Rick stein’s mini brioche toasts with whipped feta, fresh figs and pickled walnuts

‘I always think that canapés should box slightly above their weight – in other words, they need to be vividly flavoured to succeed. Here, the combination of crisp brioche, salty feta, pickled walnuts, figs, honey and thyme is just that. If you like, there’s a recipe for pickling your own green walnuts on page 275 of Rick Stein’s Christmas. You can also make this with slices of goat’s cheese from a log instead of the whipped feta.’

Recipe
S’mores Spiderweb Cookies

These adorably spooky cookies are the perfect Halloween biscuit, with a perfect chocolate crumb and a coating of marshmallow cobwebs. You can also create a seasonal variation for Bonfire Night featuring a sprinkling of edible gold dust.

Looking for more recipes?

See all recipes
penguin pop image
penguin pop image